ORNL/Sub/88-SB844/2

EVALUATION OF HERBACEOUS BIOMASS CROPS IN THE NORTHERN GREAT PLAINS

Final Report
August 31, 1994

D.W. Meyer
W.E. Norby
D.O. Erickson
R. G. Johnson

North Dakota Agricultural Experiment Station
North Dakota State University
Fargo, North Dakota

under Subcontract 19X-SB844C
Research supported by Biofuels System Division
Office of Transportation Technologies
Activity No. EB 24 13 01 0

for
Biofuels Feedstock Development Program
OAK RIDGE NATIONAL LABORATORY
Oak Ridge, Tennessee 37831-6422
managed by
LOCKHEED MARTIN ENERGY RESEARCH CORP.
for the
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY
under contract DE-AC05-96OR22464


Table of Contents

Abstract
 
INTRODUCTION
 
OBJECTIVES
 
MATERIALS AND METHODS
 
Objectives 1 and 2
Objective 3
 
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
 
Precipitation
Perennial Biomass Yields
Chemical Composition of Perennial Species
Corn Grain Yields
Biomass Yield of Annuals
Chemical Composition of Annuals
Biomass Yields on a Moisture Gradient
Biomass Yields of Perennials and Annuals Compared
Biomass Cropping on Normally Fallowed Land
Economic Analysis of Biomass Cropping
Maturity Effects on Biomass Yield of Kochia
Effects of Biomass Cropping on Subsequent Crop Yields
Maturity Effects on Stand Maintenance of Perennial Grasses
 
SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS
 
LITERATURE CITED

LIST OF TABLES

Table 1. Growing-season precipitation at five North Dakota sites in 1988 to 1992
Table 2. Biomass yield of several perennial species meaned across 3 or 4 N levels at six North Dakota sites in 1989-1992
Table 3. Nitrogen level effects on average perennial biomass yields at six North Dakota sites during 1991-1992
Table 4. Chemical composition of perennial biomass species as influenced by site and year (meaned across species and N Levels)
Table 5. Significance of nitrogen effect on chemical composition of perennial biomass species at six North Dakota sites in 1989-92 (meaned across species)
Table 6. Chemical composition of several perennial biomass species at six North Dakota sites (meaned across years and 3 or 4 N levels
Table 7. Significance of species on chemical composition of perennial biomass species at six North Dakota sites in 1989-92
Table 8. Yield of eight chemical components of perennial biomass species at six North Dakota sites in 1989-92 (meaned across species and N levels)
Table 9. Grain yield of corn by N level and cropping system at six North Dakota sites in 1988-92
Table 10. Biomass yield of annual herbaceous crops as affected by cropping system at two sites in North Dakota (mean of species and N levels)
Table 11. Biomass yield by cropping system at 50 kg N ha-1 of four annual species at six sites in North Dakota in 1988-92
Table 12. Significance of N level effect on biomass yield of annual herbaceous corps at six North Dakota sites in 1988-92 (meaned across cropping system and species.
Table 13. Chemical composition of annual biomass species at six North Dakota sites in 1988-92 mean of species and cropping system at 50 kg N ha-1 )
Table 14. Chemical composition of annual biomass species at 50 kg N ha-1 at six North Dakota sites (meaned across years and cropping systems)
Table 15 Linear regression equations of biomass yield (Mg ha-1 ) (meaned across N level) versus growing-season precipitation (mm) using an environment as the observation
Table 16. Grain yield of Hazen baley in 1991 following a legume biomass crop in 1990 at Carrington, ND
Table 17. Grain yield of Stoa wheat in 1991 following a legume biomass crop in 1990 at Carrington, ND
Table 18. Biomass yield and chemical composition of seeded kochia harvested at four maturity dates at Prosper, ND in 1990
Table 19. Biomass yield and chemical composition of kochia (native stand) at six maturity states at Prosper, ND in 1992
Table 20. Biomass yield and chemical composition of kochia at four harvest dates at Prosper, ND in 1992 (spring-seeded stand)
Table 21. Biomass yield of three grass species as affected by harvest date and N level at Fargo, ND, in 1992
Table 22. Biomass yield of bromegrass as affected by N level and harvest date at Fargo, ND in 1990-92.

List of Figures

Figure 1. Location of sites used in the North Dakota biomass experiments
Figure 2. Biomass yields of several perennial species/mixtures at six North Dakota sites (meaned across years and N levels)
Figure 3. Chemical composition of eight perennial biomass species/mixtures at Prosper, ND, (meaned across years and N levels). C=cellulose, L=acid-detergent lignin, H=hemicellulose, O=other cell solubles, T==total nonstructural carbohydrates, N=nitrogen, A=Ash
Figure 4. Biomass yields of annual species at 50 kg N ha-1 at six North Dakota sites (meaned across years)
Figure 5. Chemical composition of four annual biomass species at 50 kg N ha-1 Prosper, ND, (meaned across cropping systems and N levels). C=cellulose, L=acid-detergent lignin, H=hemicellulose, O=other cell solubles, T==total nonstructural carbohydrates, N=nitrogen, A=Ash
Figure 6. Biomass yields for six perennial species/mixtures plotted versus growing-season precipitation. Each symbol represents a biomass yield meaned across N levels with a site and year
Figure 7. Biomass yields for four annual species plotted versus growing-season precipitation. Each symbol represents a biomass yield at 50 kg N ha-1 within a site and year