Energy Crops Forum
Spring 2001
U.S. Department of Energy
Bioenergy Feedstock Development Program at
Oak Ridge National Laboratory

Energy Crops Forum was published periodically by the Bioenergy Feedstock Development Program, Environmental Sciences Division, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, managed by UT-Battelle, LLC., for the U.S. Department of Energy under Contract No. DE-AC05-00OR22725.

line

Table of Contents

line

DOE'S National Bioenergy Center includes Feedstock Research and Analysis

In October, 2000, the Department of Energy (DOE) established a National Bioenergy Center to create new economic opportunities for farmers, enhance U.S. Energy Security, and help manage the impact of energy on the environment. The Center will partner with industry to achieve cost and performance goals to make bioenergy competitive globally; provide strategic guidance, direction and coordination to assure the best use of national laboratory and university research capabilities; facilitate strategic partnerships to overcome market and institutional barriers; perform world-class research; and be the focal point of bioenergy analysis, information, education, and outreach.

The National Renewable Energy Laboratory in Golden, Colorado, and the Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) in Oak Ridge, Tennessee, will form the core of this "virtual center." The efforts of the Center will support the multi-agency Bioenergy Initiative as well as core programs in biomass power and biofuels production.

A major goal will be to form strategic partnerships with other federal laboratories and universities to expand the amount and quality of expertise available to industry for helping to make bioenergy globally competitive. The first of several partnership meetings was held April 11-12, 2001, in Golden, Colorado. The report of this meeting will be published on Bioenergy Initiative's website.

ORNL's primary contribution to the center is to supply expertise on biomass feedstock research, analysis, and engineering systems. This expertise will be drawn both from ORNL staff and the many collaborators of the Bioenergy Feedstock Development Programs (BFDP).

line

The Bioenergy Feedstock Development Programs at ORNL

ORNL provides technical leadership in feedstock research through two tightly integrated programs: Biopower Feedstock Development Program and Biofuels Feedstock Development Program. These programs perform research, development, and analysis to establish that biomass supply systems can be environmentally beneficial and commercially viable. They emphasize developing new, sustainable energy resources based on solar energy captured by living plants. The research, which is supported by funds from the DOE's Office of Transportation Technologies and Office of Power Technologies, is carried out in partnership with universities, other government agencies, and the private sector. A status report, Bioenergy Feedstock Development Program Status Report, ORNL/TM-2000/292, and detailed project summaries are available online on http://bioenergy.ornl.gov/.

The successful development of new supplies of biomass for bioenergy requires a unique level of cooperation among researchers and institutions in the energy, agricultural, forestry, and environmental sectors. The Bioenergy Feedstock Development Programs at ORNL provide a mechanism for focusing and integrating the efforts of this diverse group of stakeholders. Recognizing that each has different goals, the feedstock development programs conduct operations in a way that integrates and advances objectives for energy, agriculture, forestry, and the environment. ORNL places a strong emphasis on ensuring that information from its research and analysis is available to these stakeholders and that the information is current, accurate, and understandable.

line

Upcoming Research Solicitations

Solicitations in two areas will be released in April or May, 2001. The largest solicitation will be for switchgrass research. The new work will build on previous research but will focus on regions that show the most promise in the United States. The solicitation rquests proposals for breeding, management, biotechnology and large-scale crop production. The second solicitation is asking for paper studies concerning the potential alternative energy crops and supply systems. The solicitations will be announced on the Bioenergy Information Network and several other web locations. Announcements will also be sent to potential bidders.

line

Model Wood Energy Crops Task

Jerry Tuskan, research leader

Developing wood energy crops for the regions of the United States where land availability and climate are favorable for the establishment of biomass-based energy systems is the primary goal of this task. The research strategy is designed to maximize economic returns, reduce environmental impacts, and establish sustainable biomass supply systems by optimizing per-unit-area productivity for members of the Populus and Salix genera over a substantially large portion of the United States. Productivity increases are being achieved through a combination of traditional breeding, advanced silviculture, molecular genetics, and crop protection.

Research on wood energy crops is organized into comprehensive regional crop development consortia. Each includes a tree breeding program supported by research ranging from silvicultural trials and insect and disease evaluations to basic physiology studies and biotechnology applications. This integration has been very effective in promoting efficient exchange of information and plant materials among researchers within and across regions.

line

Model Herbaceous Energy Crops Task

Sandy McLaughlin, research leader

This task is working to develop herbaceous energy crops that can be economically produced on a wide variety of sites and incorporated into conventional farming operations. These energy crops must be environmentally acceptable and convertible into specific energy products. A model crop system has been developed focusing primarily on switchgrass (Panicum virgatum), a native perennial warm-season grass that is both highly productive and well suited to diverse agricultural sites.

The research strategy has been to use screening studies to identify promising species and varieties and to develop effective production practices. Breeding programs and cropping systems research are then used to further improve production potential. Current switchgrass research includes breeding and physiological studies and larger scale trials to develop improved cropping systems.

line

Integrated Analysis Task

Marie Walsh, research leader

BFDP and collaborators are conducting biomass resource and economic analysis needed by policymakers, the private sector, and others interested in the development of biomass energy systems. Alone and in partnerships with other government agencies and collaborators, several models and databases are being developed or modified at different scales. For example, the Biomass Resource Database contains state-level estimates, prices, and quantities of forest, mill, and agricultural residues, urban wood wastes, and energy crops whereas BIOCOST estimates regional switchgrass, poplar, and willow production costs. Other models evaluate alternative herbaceous material collection, transport, storage, and handling options or the economic potential for, and impact of energy crop production. Evaluations of the Conservation Reserve Program as an energy crop source (with the U.S. Department of Agriculture), use of short-rotation woody crops as a fiber crop (with the U.S. Forest Service), estimation of the potential for biomass co-firing, and estimation of macroeconomic impacts of establishing a corn stover to ethanol industry in the Midwest have been recently completed.

line

Environmental Sustainability Task

Virginia Tolbert, research leader

The projects in this task are compiling data to demonstrate that biomass crops can be established, managed, and harvested in an environmentally acceptable manner. Research focuses on three critical areas -- water quality, soil sustainability, and biodiversity. Information from this initial research can be used by project developers who must address specific concerns and meet local, state, and national environmental regulations.

Water quality, including non-point source pollution from agricultural practices, is an increasing concern to both regulators and the public. Soil sustainability is of major concern to crop producers, potential users of energy crops, and environmental groups that take a long-term view of environmental issues. Biodiversity, particularly wildlife diversity, is a major environmental issue because of the continued loss and fragmentation of natural habitats. Data specific to energy crops and relevant to these environmental concerns must be available to ensure that these concerns can be addressed and will not become roadblocks to the commercialization of bioenergy systems.

line

Operational Support and Evaluation Task

Mark Downing, research leader

The goal of this task is to document and quantify bioenergy feedstock production practices, productivities, and costs under operational conditions. Data collected by this task become input to the Integrated Analysis and Systems Engineering tasks, and operational issues that arise help establish research priorities for the biomass crop development tasks. The task also provides technical support on feedstock production and supply issues to cost-shared projects developing and demonstrating a range of bioenergy technologies. Another significant element is communicating information on energy crop technologies to the bioenergy project development community, equipment developers, and others requiring specific information based on operational experience.

line

Systems Engineering Task

Shahab Sokhansanj, research leader

The near-term objective of the task is to ensure cost-competitiveness of biofuels. Research will be directed towards understanding the impacts of collection, storage, and transportation on biomass feedstock availability. The overall goal is to establish safe and sustainable supply systems in support of the entire biobased industry. The task will support multidisciplinary platforms that require engineering expertise in systems optimization and scale-up technologies.

Current research is focused on efficient handling of crop residue (straw and stover) for biofuels and harvesting and treatment of energy crops (grasses and woody crop) for biopower. Research topics include development of moisture relations for corn stover, data on physical characteristics of grasses, and storage stability of corn stover and switchgrass. The results will provide critical data for optimizing machinery and systems for the entire feedstock supply chain.

line

Residue Analysis Task

Bob Perlack, research leader

The goal of this task is to expand the use of urban and industrial wastes, agricultural residues, logging residues, and other forest residues, such as those from forest fire risk areas, for use in the production of energy and biobased products. This task directly supports the Integrated Analysis and Systems Engineering tasks with the development of analytical methods and analyses.

Specific activities include the development of a method for estimating the availability and costs of utilizing agricultural, forest, urban, and industrial residues for biopower production; the estimation of the quantity, costs, characteristics, and environmental risks and benefits of using specific residues; the initiation of a study to evaluate residue handling and processing costs as well as determining the impact of any quality constraints necessary for various biopower applications; and the identification of regulatory and infrastructure barriers to greater utilization of these feedstocks. The task specifically seeks cooperation and development of partnerships with biopower producers.

line

Upcoming Meeting

Fifth International Biomass Conference of the Americas, Orlando, Florida, September 17-21, 2001. Papers and posters, September 18-20; optional technical tours, September 21.

Sponsoring Organizations: U.S. Department of Energy (Offices of Power, Fuels, and Industrial, Technologies), U.S. Department of Agriculture, Natural Resources Canada, and National Renewable Energy Laboratory.

Preliminary Topics

  • •Biomass resources - advances in biomass production, residues availability, soil sustainability, and related environmental topics
  • •Bioenergy products - advances in conversion for a wide range of bioenergy products
  • •Integrating emerging technologies with conventional energy systems - exploring synergisms
  • •Biobased products - advances in production of commodities, intermediate products, fine and specialty chemicals, and natural fibers and derivatives
  • •Biomass refineries: the link between biobased and bioenergy products - food/forest products refineries; emerging refineries based on sugars, syn gas, and new fractionation technologies
  • •Environmental and ecological impacts of bioenergy and biobased products - includes life cycle analysis and impact assessment methodologies
  • •Public/private partnerships - examples of success stories
  • •Social acceptability of bioenergy and biobased products - international, regional, national, and local approaches and methodologies
  • •Policies for market development - federal, state, and local programs; policy framework development to accelerate penetration; and incorporation of externalities

For additional information: Fifth International Biomass Conference of the Americas, National Renewable Energy Laboratory, Attention: Dee Scheaffer, 1617 Cole Boulevard, MS-1613, Golden, Colorado, USA 80401- 3393, Fax: 303-275-2905. Information about the conference can be found online at http://www.fsec.ucf.edu/bioam/

line